Skip to main content

    The Jury Duty Phone Scam: Why It Works

    The fake jury duty warrant scam has scammed seniors out of over $200 million since 2022. Here is why it feels real and how to stop it.

    6 min read · 7 steps · Checked July 2026

    1. Step 1. Understand the standard jury duty scam script

      The caller identifies themselves as a deputy or investigator from your county sheriff. They know your name (bought from data brokers). They tell you: (1) You missed jury duty on [a specific date]. (2) A judge issued a "failure to appear" warrant. (3) You will be arrested at your home unless you pay the fine within 2 hours. (4) The fine is $1,500-$4,000, payable only in gift cards, cryptocurrency, or wire transfer. (5) They stay on the phone with you while you drive to a store to buy the gift cards.

      Warning

      Real courts do not accept gift cards, cryptocurrency, or wire transfer for anything. Ever. If the "payment method" is a gift card, it is 100% a scam, no exceptions.

    2. Step 2. Why the caller ID looks real

      Modern scammers use "caller ID spoofing" — free software makes any incoming call display any number they want. They pick the actual phone number of your local sheriff's office. You look at your phone and it says "SHERIFF DEPT — DO NOT MISS." This is why you cannot use caller ID to decide if a call is real. If a call from any government agency asks for payment, the caller ID does not matter — hang up.

    3. Step 3. The three sentences that end any scam call

      (1) "I do not do business over the phone. I will call you back at the number on your official website." (2) "I need to hang up and verify this call. What is your badge number and the case number?" (3) "This is not how real courts contact people. Goodbye." Any real government caller will accept #1 without argument. Any scammer will get angry, threaten you, or try to keep you on the line. That anger is confirmation. Hang up.

      Quick Tip

      Quick Tip: Print these three sentences on a card and keep it by your phone. When you are in a real scam call, you are frightened. Reading the sentences aloud is easier than remembering them.

    4. Step 4. What real jury duty communication looks like

      Real jury duty summons arrive by U.S. Mail on official letterhead about 4-6 weeks before your service date. You get a paper form to fill out and return. If you miss the date, the court sends another letter with a reschedule option. The court does NOT call you. If you truly missed jury duty and the court is upset, they send a "failure to appear" summons in the mail — again on official letterhead — asking you to come to a hearing. There is no phone call. There is no arrest warrant for missing one day of jury duty.

    5. Step 5. What to do if a scammer says a warrant is out for your arrest

      Hang up. Then, if you are worried, verify from the real source: (1) Google your county name + "clerk of court" or "sheriff's office." Call the number listed on the official .gov website. Ask: "Is there an active warrant for [your name and date of birth]?" They will look you up. If nothing exists, the call was a scam. (2) In most states you can also check yourself at your county's public records website (county name + "court records lookup"). (3) Filing a "wellness check" on yourself is possible — sheriff's deputies can come by to confirm no warrant exists, but this is overkill and usually not needed.

    6. Step 6. Report the scam call

      File a report at reportfraud.ftc.gov (5 minutes, no account needed). Also report to your local sheriff's office non-emergency line. They track how many people in your county are getting the same call. The FBI accepts reports at ic3.gov if any money was lost. Blocking the number on your phone does not help much because scammers use a different number every call, but if you use a call-blocking app like Nomorobo or the free RoboKiller trial, they add these numbers to a shared block list within hours.

    7. Step 7. Set your phone to only ring for people you know

      On iPhone: Settings > Phone > Silence Unknown Callers > toggle On. Any number not in your contacts goes straight to voicemail. Real people leave a voicemail. Scammers rarely do. On Android: Phone app > three-dot menu > Settings > Caller ID & spam > toggle "See caller and spam ID" and "Filter spam calls." On Samsung, it is Phone > Settings > Block numbers > Block unknown numbers. This one change stops about 90% of scam calls from ever ringing.

      Quick Tip

      Quick Tip: If you are worried about missing an important call from a doctor or a repair person, ask them to text you first when they plan to call. Real callers with real business are happy to do that.

    The jury duty phone scam has been the FTC's most-reported phone scam three years running. The pitch: you missed jury duty; there is a warrant out for your arrest; pay $2,000 in gift cards or by wire to the "sheriff" and the warrant will be canceled.

    Since 2022, this scam has taken over $200 million from Americans, most of it from seniors. It works because scammers have gotten very good at making it sound official — real courthouse names, real sheriff-deputy titles, real case numbers, spoofed caller ID showing the actual sheriff's office phone number.

    There is one thing you need to remember and everything else falls into place: no court, no sheriff, no government agency in the United States will ever call you and demand payment over the phone. Not for missed jury duty. Not for unpaid taxes. Not for anything. Ever.

    This guide walks through why the scam feels real, the exact scripts scammers use, and the three sentences you can say to end any government-impersonation call in 10 seconds.

    (Sources: FTC Consumer Alerts — consumer.ftc.gov; FBI Internet Crime Complaint Center — ic3.gov; National Center for State Courts — ncsc.org)

    Official sources

    Still stuck?

    A real person can walk you through it over the phone.

    Get help from a person

    Related guides